News

Judge questions Colorado ICE chief over rearrests of released detainees

At least 18 people were quickly taken back into custody after being ordered released from immigration detention in Aurora. Now, a federal judge is questioning leadership over the ICE rearrests and considering contempt proceedings.

Two Colorado ICE agents stand beside a white car during an enforcement stop in Denver, illustrating a report on ICE rearrests of released detainees.
ICE agents make a stop along Washington Street Wednesday, Sept. 16, 2026, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski)

Imagine this: A federal judge orders someone released from immigration detention, only for ICE rearrests to happen the moment they step outside. They walk out of the facility,  sun finally on their face, an air of freedom greeting them as they think for a moment that maybe the system is just and this country is what they hoped it was. In an instant all of those thoughts disappear as ICE agents descend upon them again. 

That’s what happened outside Aurora’s immigration detention center, where at least 18 people were released and swiftly re-arrested over the course of a week in late October, according to federal court testimony.

Now, a federal judge is considering whether to initiate contempt proceedings after summoning the acting head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Denver field office to explain the practice.

During a hearing on Nov. 9, US District Judge Charlotte Sweeney questioned Nathan Rasper, ICE’s acting Denver field office director, about why agents were taking people back into custody despite court orders requiring their release.

Why were ICE rearrests happening?

Rasper testified that he authorized the practice on Oct. 27, believing ICE could legally re-arrest people after correcting problems with their original arrest paperwork.

He said he had consulted ICE’s legal advisers but he didn’t know about an agreement between federal prosecutors and the court governing how certain immigration detention cases should be handled.

The people affected had sought release through habeas corpus petitions, which allow individuals to challenge the legality of their detention before a federal judge. But for some, winning those challenges didn’t mean they could go home.

Carlos Garcia told Colorado Public Radio that agents rearrested him on Oct. 27 after he had taken just a single step outside the Aurora facility.

Garcia described being handcuffed, transported with other detainees to an ICE office in Centennial, and returned to detention.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado has also documented cases in which people were re-arrested immediately after being released, arguing that the practice violated court orders and constitutional protections.

What happened in court?

Sweeney admonished ICE’s handling of the releases, questioning whether the agency believed it could determine the legality of its actions independently after a federal court had already ruled.

“Releasing somebody momentarily is not releasing somebody at all,” Sweeney said during an earlier hearing, according to The Denver Gazette.

At Monday’s hearing, she called the re-arrests violation of due process and said they created  fear among people awaiting release.

Rasper testified that he ordered the practice stopped on November 4th, following the judge’s questioning. 

ICE has maintained that it has legal authority to make arrests under federal immigration law. Rasper said he believed the re-arrests were lawful, although he admitted he had not reviewed the individual case that prompted Sweeney’s inquiry.

What happens to the detainees now?

Naturally, the controversy is bigger than a single case. Other Colorado federal judges have questioned if ICE is in compliance with release orders, including times when the agency imposed monitoring conditions that judges hadn’t implemented.

The ACLU has identified at least 17 cases involving people who remained detained despite release orders—testimony at Monday’s hearing established at least 18 quickfire re-arrests.

The dispute also follows an earlier Colorado legal battle over ICE’s authority to make warrantless arrests, as previously reported by Courier Colorado.

For those detainees, the question is simple: Will a judge’s order actually get them out of detention so they can fight their immigration cases from outside ICE custody?

Sweeney has not yet announced whether she will initiate contempt proceedings. She is expected to issue a written order addressing ICE’s conduct.

Although the agency says the rearrests have stopped, the judge’s pending decision could determine what further consequences, if any, follow from the practice.